Idina Menzel’s Most Underrated Role Is This 2007 Disney Movie Where She Didn't Sing At All (2024)

Idina Menzel's most underrated role is in the 2007 film Enchanted. Surprisingly, this is one of the very few screen roles where Menzel doesn't sing. Menzel is most famous for her musical roles as Maureen in Rent and Elsa in Frozen, as well as her groundbreaking Broadway career. Meanwhile, in Enchanted, Menzel plays Robert's (Patrick Dempsey) girlfriend, Nancy Tremaine. However, when Giselle (Amy Adams) ends up with Robert, Nancy leaves with Prince Edward (James Marsden) and lives happily ever after in Andalasia.

✕ Remove Ads

Although she doesn't sing in Enchanted, Menzel returned for the film's sequel, joining Disenchanted's cast. As well as getting the chance to sing in this installment, Menzel is reunited with most of the original cast from the first installment and expands upon her role as Nancy, now the queen of Andalasia. Nancy's role in the sequel is a lot bigger, with more effect on the plot's outcome in Disenchanted's ending, while showcasing the aspect of her career she is best known for.

Idina Menzel Was Happy To Be Just An Actress In Enchanted

Menzel Didn't Have To Sing In The First Enchanted Movie

✕ Remove Ads

In an interview with PEOPLE, Menzel revealed that she was happy to have been cast in Enchanted based on her acting ability alone. The Broadway actress is usually cast in singing roles, and it is interesting to see her only have to act. Nancy's character contributes to the movie's overall theme of believing in happy endings, wanting her own fairy tale romance, and she is the opposite of Giselle. Whereas Giselle comes from Andalasia to the real world, by the end of the film, Nancy has gone from this world to live with Edward in Andalasia.

Menzel's Enchanted character’s name, Nancy Tremaine, is a reference to Cinderella's evil stepmother, Lady Tremaine; Nancy was also about to become Morgan's stepmother.

It makes sense for Nancy's role to only consist of acting. As a real-world character, she is portrayed as a regular human who doesn't randomly break into song. Additionally, she is a realistic version of the stereotype of the evil stepmother. Morgan (Rachel Covey) looks up to Giselle and wants to be a princess like her, while Nancy (understandably) doesn't like the fact that Giselle is staying with her boyfriend and his daughter. The way she has a different worldview than Giselle shows where the conflict with Morgan comes from.

✕ Remove Ads

Most Of Idina Menzel's Screen Roles Are Singing Roles

Menzel Usually Has To Sing Because of Her Broadway Experience

Since she originated the role of Elphaba in Wicked on Broadway, Menzel has been in high demand for musical roles both on stage and screen. She has appeared on-screen in Rent, Frozen, Cinderella, Beaches, and Glee, in all of which she had to sing. Most of her on-screen singing roles are iconic in one way or another. The obvious example is her singing "Let It Go" in Frozen as it has become one of the most well-known Disney songs of all time, as well as thematically and stylistically recalling the Wicked power ballad "Defying Gravity."

Related

If The Wicked Movie Ignores This Actor, I Won't Be Able To Forgive It

The new Wicked movie features a new cast as well, but the film should celebrate its origins by giving both of its first leading ladies cameos.

✕ Remove Ads

Menzel has been delivering iconic on-screen musical numbers for decades, from "Take Me or Leave Me" in the 2005's Rent to a cover of Madonna's "Material Girl" in the 2021 musical film remake of Cinderella. Menzel's powerful belting vocals and dynamic persona make her amazing to watch in movie and TV musicals. However, her performance in Enchanted demands even more respect as she can play the role of the evil stepmother without being perceived as evil, and without depending on her singing talent.

Idina Menzel Did Get To Sing In The Sequel Disenchanted

Nancy Returns From Andalasia Delivering New Songs In Disenchanted

Idina Menzel’s Most Underrated Role Is This 2007 Disney Movie Where She Didn't Sing At All (2)

✕ Remove Ads

Menzel was given two songs to sing in the sequel Disenchanted. The first is a chipper duet with Marsden as Edward called "The Magic of Andalasia." However, Menzel's second is a solo called "Love Power," deferring to her famous belting style of singing and widely advertised as part of the movie's branding. When she was asked about how she felt about singing in the sequel to Enchanted, Menzel said:

"I was happy to be hired as just an actress, but now I'm really excited because these songs, Stephen Schwartz and Alan Menken wrote, the songs are incredible. But there's so much music, and Amy [Adams] singing her butt off, and it's just Patrick [Dempsey] singing and tap dancing. It's really glorious and joyful and people are going to love it."

Although it was great to see Menzel simply act in the original film, it makes perfect sense for Nancy to sing in Disenchanted. Nancy had been living in Andalasia for 15 years, meaning that elements of the magical, animated land have been imprinted on her, and she is now able to break into song and dance. The fact that she sings in the sequel allows the character to change and adapt from her depiction in Enchanted, and she can help save the day through song.

✕ Remove Ads

Source: PEOPLE

Idina Menzel’s Most Underrated Role Is This 2007 Disney Movie Where She Didn't Sing At All (3)

Your Rating

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

7/10

Enchanted

PG

Animation

Romance

Comedy

Fantasy

Musical

Family

Starring Amy Adams as Giselle, Enchanted follows its heroine as she is cast out of her animated fantasy world by an evil queen, ending up in the middle of New York City where she meets Robert, a jaded lawyer who reluctantly takes the clueless Giselle in. As Giselle begins to adjust to life in the real world, and her relationship with Robert deepens, she must reconcile what she thought she wanted with where life has taken her. Patrick Dempsey, James Marsden, Idina Menzel, and Susan Sarandon also star.

Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

*Availability in US

Director
Kevin Lima

Release Date
November 21, 2007
Studio(s)
Disney

Runtime
107 minutes
Sequel(s)
Disenchanted

Writers
Bill Kelly
Cast
Patrick Dempsey , Amy Adams , Timothy Spall , Susan Sarandon , Idina Menzel , James Marsden
Idina Menzel’s Most Underrated Role Is This 2007 Disney Movie Where She Didn't Sing At All (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Horacio Brakus JD

Last Updated:

Views: 6007

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Horacio Brakus JD

Birthday: 1999-08-21

Address: Apt. 524 43384 Minnie Prairie, South Edda, MA 62804

Phone: +5931039998219

Job: Sales Strategist

Hobby: Sculling, Kitesurfing, Orienteering, Painting, Computer programming, Creative writing, Scuba diving

Introduction: My name is Horacio Brakus JD, I am a lively, splendid, jolly, vivacious, vast, cheerful, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.